Figure5illustrates the fatigue life of the specimens for different values of hole diameter at different loading conditions. Pdf fatigue life extension by crack repair using stophole. Arresting cracks in steel bridges amazon web services. A series of fatigue crack growth tests was performed using doubleedgepre cracked specimens. However, fatigue crack initiation cannot be prevented in some. If the crack is caused by fatigue, do we need a pin to support the drill hole, or does the hole itself suffice to stop the propagation. The results indicate that the corrosive environment greatly reduces the effect of the stop holes, and that stop holes of diameter 15 mm give a longer delay than stop holes of diameter 5 or 10 mm. Funded by the kansas department of transportation kdot and the ku transportation institute. Repairing cracked steel structures with carbon fiber. Stop drill fatigue cracks that have begun to propagate can sometimes be stopped by drilling holes, called drill stops, at the tip of the crack. The most common measure applied to bridges with fatigue cracks consists of drilling crackstop holes at the tips of cracks. A hole drilled at the end of a crack to stop the crack where it is. Fatigue enhancement of undersized, drilled crackstop holes.
Stophole conditions to prevent reinitiation of fatigue cracks fatigue. New crack stop hole shape using structural optimizing technique. As the crack extends, the remaining intact area of the cross section reduces, possibly leading to complete fracture, or failure by another mode such as jamming or seizure of a mechanism. Most of the research works on this subject are limited to fatigue cracks subjected to mode i loading conditions. It is well known that drilling a hole crackstop hole. The double stop drill hole method can be used to increase the fatigue life of the cracked components. Reduce temperature of the fluid or ambient air to within the hoses working limits, andor replace the hose with one that has a higher qualified temperature rating. Introduction one of the easiest and most accessible crack arresting methods is drilling holes close to the crack tip.
The results indicate that cold expansion and interferencefit fastener installation improve the fatigue performance of stop drill holes through crack tips by factors ranging from 3 to 20. The manual for our r182 calls for no more than six cracks per skin, and refers to cracks through or emanating from the rivets. Pdf fatigue life extension by crack repair using stop. A technical method for arresting further crack growth from cracks by drilling holes in the vicinity of the crack tips was investigated. How to treat alligator cracking as a general rule, whenever you see any cracks appear in your asphalt, the first thing you should do is apply crack filler or sealcoating, weather permitting, to try to halt further spread of damage. By analyzing the effects of flank holes and an additional hole, drilling advice was proposed and fatigue testing of the cracks in a steel bridge deck with a crack stop hole was conducted. As the 58yearold seaplane gently climbed toward the cloud ceiling, numerous fatigue cracks in the metal structure of the right wing grew a bit more one last time allowing the aerodynamic load to snap off the entire right wing. Analysis of fatigue crack growth from cold expanded interference fitted stop drilled holes executive summary when fatigue cracks are found in aircraft structures the safe life of the structure is of concern.
Where fatigue cracking initiates in plain material remote from any welds, a welded repair may be practical, but it will certainly have a much reduced fatigue life unless particular attention is paid to improvement of the fatigue strength andor cyclic stress at the original crack initiation site. The stopholes grondin and kulak, 2010 retrofit, where holes are drilled at the tips of existing cracks, has been customarily adopted by many dots across the u. The technique of retarding the growth of fatigue cracks by drilling holes on the crack tip is well known. The main concept of double stop hole method is to reduce the stress concentration at the edge of stop holes in the cracked structural elements. If ambient heat is the cause, install heat guards or shields as required, and replace the hose assembly. Ftis stopcrackex system cold expands a bushing into a drill stop, imparting residual compressive stresses around it, protecting it from cyclic loads.
For the specimens containing stopholes, six circular or elliptical stop holes were drilled in each cracked ect specimen using wireelectrode cutting. Based on the stress profiles, stopcrackex will provide better fatigue life compared to drill stop method. This technique is intended to eliminate the sharp termination of the crack and replace it with a smooth radius, lowering crack growth propensity by reducing the stressconcentration factor. A stressbased multiaxial fatigue criterion is adopted to estimate the crack initiation on the perimeter of a stop hole. This is a viable method listed in my student pilot handbook so im curious how i should evaluate the integrity of the structure if i come across a stop drilled crack. Behaviour of skin fatigue cracks at the corners of windows. Stress concentrations are typically due to a parts geometry such as radiuses or bends, material defects, manufacturing defects, corrosion, wear, or. A common technique to prevent the propagation of fatigue cracks in bridge girders is to drill crackstop holes at crack tips.
Stophole conditions to prevent reinitiation of fatigue. Things to keep in mind to prevent material fatigue. Most of the existing research works on this subject are focusing on cracks subjected to modei loading. Macfarlane makes a bulb with the right taper to it. I have had good luck with using 2part epoxy, and glueing a piece of plastic on to the back of the crack. The main idea of the method is to reduce stress concentration at the edges of stopdrilled holes. Fatigue is one of the primary reasons for the failure of structural components. Development of a technique to improve fatigue lives of. Small cracks can be blended away and the surface cold worked or shot peened. The life of a fatigue crack has two parts, initiation and propagation. The drill stop process could have crack initiation at as low as 6. This prepares students to be able to put data from an associated statistical analysis activity into context as they conduct meticulous statistical analyses to evaluatedetermine the effectiveness of carbon fiber patches to repair steel. Enhanced stop drill repair procedure for cracked structures. The results show that the stress at the crack tip with a crack stop hole decreased, and the major principal stress around the hole was distributed accordingly.
Inserting pins into drilled stopholes is effective to arrest the crack. You will have to register or login see top or bottom of page before you can post a message or view images. Fatigue cracks caused hole in southwest jet the new york. Comparisons of the life predictions and fatigue test data are also presented. If you dont care about looks, drill two small holes and use tiny zip ties to hold the crack together. Fatigue and fracture research group university of kansas. If a crack is found, a common repair method is to drill a round hole at the end. Whats a stop drill crack on an auto or airplanes body. How does stop drilling arrest metal crack propagation. Stress concentrations at the crack tips are reduced and fatigue life of the bridge is extended.
By doing so, stress concentrations at the tip of the cracks are reduced and fatigue life of the bridge is extended. Either way, once alligator cracking begins, it will not stop without proper asphalt repair. The size of the crackstop hole is determined by utilizing known material properties and relationships. A series of fatiguecrackgrowth tests was performed using doubleedgeprecracked specimens. An easy technique to arrest or retard the growth of fatigue cracks is the drilling of stop holes. The main concept of double stophole method is to reduce the stress concentration at the edge of stopholes in the cracked.
The states of a fatigue crack before and after repair with a stop hole are shown in figure 5 and 6, respectively. In some specimens, holes were drilled in the vicinity of the crack tips. Then, when two additional holes are drilled near the stop drilling hole so as to face each other symmetrically, the stress concentration of the stop drilling hole can be relaxed further, and a fatigue life is extended. A common technique used to prevent the propagation of cracks in bridge girders is drilling crackstop holes at the crack tips. Dislocations play a major role in the fatigue crack initiation phase. Fatigue life extension by crack repair using stophole technique. The system consists of pulling a tapered mandrel lined with a. Evaluation of the performance of retrofit measures for dif. Since stopholes are regarded as an emergency measure to delay crack. Arrests the growth of small cracks in holes costeffective. The possibility remains of a new crack starting in the side of the hole. The test on galyr showed that fatigue cracks were initiated earliest and most numerously at the windows in the centre section, and though the first failure in galyu was at a forward escape hatch 4. Many fatigue cracks in bridge structures are drill stopped to repair the bridge. It is better than any fatigue crack does not initiate in engineering applications.
What to do when you see alligator cracking in asphalt. Recommended method for repairing fatigue cracking twi. Fatigue life extension by crack repair using double stop. Development of a technique to improve fatigue lives of crackstop holes in steel bridges. First, it is necessary to keep in mind that any variation in part or mechanical component sections are special regions where stress will concentrate, which will affect their. While on the subject of dislocations, it is appropriate to briefly discuss fatigue. The implementation of retrofits to stop fatigue crack growth in steel girder bridges has shown variable success. Over several days, students learn about composites, including carbonfiberreinforced polymers, and their applications in modern life. Drilling holes in the vicinity of the crack tip turns the crack into a notch and reduces the crack tip stress intensity factor. Most of the time it is an interim measure until a real fix can be accomplished.
It can be seen that for the specimens repaired with 3mm and 2mm diameter stop holes, the highest and the lowest fatigue lives are resulted. Fatigue cracks are in many cases very fine, remaining tightly closed at minimum load and hence difficult to find by visual examination alone. The numerical results reveal that the presence of stop holes significantly decreases the stress concentration around the crack tip. Make sure you dont have any airbag modules behind where youre drilling. From the meaning that the drilled holes stop the propagation of cracks, they are called stopholes.
The results indicate that cold expansion and interferencefit fastener installation improve the fatigue performance of stopdrill holes through crack tips by factors ranging from 3 to 20. The unstable growth of fatigue cracks brings a material or structure to catastrophic failure. However, the size and the location of the additional hole suitable for repairing the fatigue damage are not clarified yet. In steel bridges fatigue cracks are sometimes repaired by placing drilled holes at the crack tips. The stop drilling technique involves drilling small circular hole near the crack tip. Fatigue life extension by crack repair using stophole.
The stopholes grondin and kulak, 2010 retrofit, where holes are drilled at the tips of existing cracks, has been customarily adopted by many departments of transportation across the u. Three stopdrill holes were noted in the area of the doubler repair to the lower skin at ws 34. Table 2 summarizes the number of delay cycles nd caused by the stopholes under the several testing conditions studied in this program. While stopholes are an effective method to stop fatigue crack growth, the.
Relaxation of stress concentration of a crack by stop. Once it was confirmed that fatigue cracks were propagating to the base material of the deck plate, the fatigue test was interrupted and then resumed after stop holes were made at the tip of the fatigue cracks. Effect of stophole on fatigue at vertical stiffener welds. Stress concentration at stopdrilled holes and additional. Preventing and repairing fatigue cracking in steel bridges is a major problem facing bridge engineers at the kansas department of transportation kdot.
This question has intrigued many people, including the materialistic skeptics, probably because deep down, at the most elemental level of our core self, everyone can sense and comprehend the importance of retaining and sustaining the wellbeing of their energy fields. This behaviour was observed for different loading conditions. The fatigue crack growth retardation is examined using an experimental investigation coupled with a. Enhancing effectiveness of crack arrest holes using. Some researchers investigated arresting crack initiation at stopdrilled hole by drilling ancillary holes around the principle stop hole murdani et al. Split sleeve coldworking stops the ocurrence of fatigue cracks around fastener holes in metal structures. Numerical estimation of the stop holesinduced fatigue. The holes on the crack tip transform the stress singularity of the crack to a notch, reducing thus the driving force for further crack propagation. Cracks less than 18inch thick are considered stress cracks and are harmless, while cracks 14inch wide and larger are often more serious.
By analyzing the effects of flank holes and an additional hole, drilling advice was proposed and fatigue testing of the cracks in a steel bridge deck. The fatigue cracks that caused the hole would not have been apparent on a visual inspection, an official said, while cracks were found on two more jets. Effect of weld discontinuities on fatigue of aluminum butt. Because of the potential for damage, kdot regularly inspects its bridges for cracking. In this paper, a new idea is used in which instead of a single hole, two symmetric and interconnected holes are drilled at the crack tip. The stop hole method is a simple and accessible crack arresting method widely used to retard and even to stop the fatigue crack propagation in structural components that cannot be replaced as soon. How to determine if the cracks in walls are serious hunker. Inspect the position of the crack after measuring its width. The skins are too thin and flex too much, and cessnas trailing edge bulb extrusion has parallel sides that stresses the skin when the rivets are bucked. Extend the fatigue life of drill stops by over 10x. If the crack is in a critical component, such as a spar, or other support structure, that method is not approved. Test program preliminary tests preliminary fatigue tests were made on sound welds to study the effects of 1 8 in. However, drill stopping may only stop a crack from growing for a short time. The crack tip stop hole is used to diminish stress singularity of the crack tip in order to improve the fatigue life of structure.
270 304 449 299 1285 1204 14 879 148 35 1433 963 1089 933 612 895 924 956 1068 1260 695 639 870 686 35 1318 357 1159 527 1328 850 1124 146 235 1314 168 244 500 1078 702 1127 1241 969 632 97 511